There are three possible reasons why Silda Dean wrote a letter saying she lied when she claimed to have been molested by Scott Dean, the former county commissioner and Harlem mayor who adopted the girl and four of her siblings from Guatemala:
• She was lying then, but now she’s telling the truth.
• She was telling the truth then, but she’s lying now because of pressure or persuasion.
• She was telling the truth then, but she’s lying now because she’s appointed herself as Dean’s personal pardons and paroles board and has decided a year in prison is enough punishment.