Current weather

  • Broken clouds
  • 66°
    Broken clouds
  • Comment

Homeowners associations aren't the bad guys

Posted: September 19, 2012 - 12:03am

How many times do we need to see this same plot before we figure out how the movie ends?

A homeowner in a neighborhood fails to live up to the civil agreement that governs the community, and then complains that the community’s governing body is picking on him or her. The community comes out looking like the bad guy just for trying to make sure everyone plays by the same rules.

We saw it play out last year on a national stage when Homes for Our Troops tried to bully the Knob Hill subdivision in Evans into allowing the group to build a home that didn’t meet the neighborhood’s guidelines.

Despite being falsely accused of disliking veterans – the home was for a disabled vet – the homeowners association stuck to its guns. HFOT was able to build the home elsewhere, but it’ll take a while for Knob Hill to recover from the slander.

More recently, there’s the tempest in a teapot in the Millshaven neighborhood in Martinez. Becky Rogers-Peck is being sued because an outbuilding on her property is painted colors that the HOA says aren’t compatible with the neighborhood.

Just as Homes for Our Troops tried to justify bending the rules in Knob Hill because they were trying to help a disabled veteran, Rogers-Peck argues in favor of the pink-and-purple structure because it’s a playhouse for her granddaughter.

“Why do they have the right to tell me what to do on the property that I pay for?” Rogers-Peck asks.

Why? For the same reason any homeowners association has the right to decide what meets their neighborhood’s standards. It’s right there in the contract governing the homeowners association in the first place, something Rogers-Peck assuredly knows as a former board member of the Millshaven HOA.

While homeowners associations often are criticized for being nit-picky, overbearing and managed by “busybodies,” the fact remains that the organizations represent a nearly pure form of representative democracy. Members pay an even share of the funding to operate the neighborhood “government.” (Just imagine how different it would be if everyone in the United States paid an equal share of taxes.) Those homeowners agree to rules governing the neighborhood (the equivalent of a constitution), and then elect a board to act on their behalf in enforcing those rules.

The aim is to safeguard the property values of everyone who lives in the neighborhood. The effects, especially in neighborhoods where an HOA board is alert and engaged, are a stark contrast to neighborhoods without such attentiveness or where protective covenants have lapsed: Many of the latter neighborhoods are a source for frequent, and often ineffective, complaints about unkempt yards and dilapidated buildings.

Those who decry a loss of “freedom” in a neighborhood with protective covenants are being absurd. It would be just as silly to complain that a car loan infringes on your freedom because it requires you to make payments. If you don’t want to make payments, then don’t borrow money to buy a car.

Likewise, if you aren’t prepared to follow the rules of the civil contract governing a neighborhood, then don’t buy a home in a neighborhood governed by such an agreement.

Just don’t be surprised if your neighbors aren’t as interested in preserving your community’s property values.

  • Comment

Comments (21)

soapy_725

Amen and Amen

Great presentation of the truth about HOA. Sadly we live in a "me world", not a "we world". Some love laws, law abiding citizens whose wish is peace and stability. Others decry laws, the lawless, laws unto themselves who wish to being chaos. The cost is high.

BobbyHodges

And all the people said...

Amen!

ReallyDude

Thank you.

Well written, now wait for the "me-me" to bash you....here it comes.

Paul Ricca

While building a home in a

While building a home in a community it is essential to follow the guidelines thoroughly to avoid all sorts of trouble. It is best to approach reputed builders like Pinnacle Homes to buy your dream home. This company also has online presence and could be approached at http://pinnaclehomes.com/market/novi/.

Mary Chavez

If the people here are having

If the people here are having a problem with the association then they should consider holding a meeting to discuss the core issues here. However, those who are not happy with the community they live in should consider moving to other communities like Vistancia, you can find out more about this place online at www.vistancia.com/.

robertcarter

Where we love is home

I really liked your website and this article. Quite informative.
The decor styles are really cool. I think I should incorporate them in my home too.
Baden Contracting of Manassas, VA proudly serves Northern Virginia communities with expert roof, siding and gutter repair, window and door installation, Kitchen & Bathroom remodeling and custom construction work. We pride ourselves in giving clients personal attention throughout the planning stage of every project, and we’re meticulous when it comes to detail. We look forward to helping you complete projects at your home or business.
Northern Virginia roofing

robertcarter

To keep the body in good health is a duty.

I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information.
At Academy Women’s Healthcare Associates, we are committed to providing our Colorado Springs OB /GYN patients with a private practice in gynecology and obstetrics that is complete, up-to-date and patient-friendly.
OBGYN Colorado Springs

robertcarter

I am lucky: I have fantastic doctors and a fantastic dentist.

Thanks for your information. This information are very useful.
When it comes to finding the perfect dentist for all your general and cosmetic dentistry needs in the Franklin, Cool Springs, Brentwood and Nashville TN area, you want one who will make you feel comfortable and treat you with respect. You’ll find just that at Today’s Dentistry!
franklin dental care

robertcarter

I am lucky: I have fantastic doctors and a fantastic dentist.

Thanks for your information. This information are very useful.
When it comes to finding the perfect dentist for all your general and cosmetic dentistry needs in the Franklin, Cool Springs, Brentwood and Nashville TN area, you want one who will make you feel comfortable and treat you with respect. You’ll find just that at Today’s Dentistry!
franklin dental care

robertcarter

I am lucky: I have fantastic doctors

This is very useful information.Thank you.
Dr. Richard Meyer is Board Certified and the only Fellowship / Specialty Trained Orthopedic Surgeon in both hip and knee reconstruction / replacement and Sports Medicine at Touro Infirmary.
New Orleans orthopedic surgeons

robertcarter

To keep the body in good health is a duty.

This information is really helpful.Thank you for the information.

A critical feature of image-guided surgery (HIFU) is the ability to localize and verify ablation of the therapeutic target in real-time. The HIFU systems from SonaCare Medical (formerly USHIFU) combine three capabilities into one single operating platform; integrated imaging, precision ablation and real-time tissue change validation. In other words, the capability to target, treat and track the tissue of interest while sparing healthy surrounding tissue.
Miami Urologists

robertcarter

Be true to your teeth and they won't be false to you.

This is very good site.Thank you for the information.
With more than 27 years in practice, Dr. Wych has become one of the most well regarded and respected general and cosmetic dentists in the region – renowned for his expertise, good results as well as his gentle and relaxing approach. Taking extra care to perform painless procedures, Dr. Wych has essentially transformed the typically unwelcome dental visit into a comfortable and stress-free experience.
Dentists Columbia SC

robertcarter

We go on multiplying our conveniences only to multiply our cares

This site is very helpful. Thank you for the information.

Dr. Baum provides a wide variety of medical and surgical treatments, including minimally invasive, in-office procedures. Dr. Baum is available to help you address your urological concerns. As a urologist, Dr. Baum specializes in the evaluation and treatment of urological symptoms and conditions.
Prostate gland Enlargement

robertcarter

The good physician treats the disease.

This is very good site.Thank you for the information.
A new beginning in women’s health care has dawned in Montgomery County. Welcome to New Beginning’s OBGYN superior-quality, women’s comprehensive healthcare services provided by obstetrician gynecologist specialists Dr. Rania Ibrahim and Dr. Farly Sejour. Both physicians are board certified obstetrician gynecologists by the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology.
laparoscopic surgery Livingston TX

robertcarter

I am lucky: I have fantastic doctors and a fantastic dentist.

This site is very good. Thank you for the information.
The Plaza Dental Assisting School can get you started for a career that could easily offer you a salary in excess of $40,000 a year and in an industry that is in dearth of good quality, trained and certified entry level assistants.
Dental Assisting career in Indiana

robertcarter

The doctor sees all the weakness of mankind

You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging.
Our mission at Innovations in Women’s Health Corpus is to provide our patients with the highest possible quality obstetrics and personalized gynecological care in the Corpus Christi TX area.
obgyn corpus christi tx

robertcarter

I am a doctor. I have long experience with several disease.

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.
Your initial office visit/consultation begins with you answering our medical and bladder questionnaire. Your responses are entered into our custom designed computer system, ensuring an individualized and personal plan of care.
urologist New York

robertcarter

I go to the dentist every six months.

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.
Vista Smiles centers their business on the client. They have tried to make their office have more of a homely, relaxed feeling. They have a very high reputation and one of the best in the area. Vista Smiles uses all the latest technology, and most of their clients have been referred by family and friends.

Dentist Columbia SC

robertcarter

Everyone needs a coach.

This is very good information.It is very helpful.
Coach Cameron Roberts is Australasia’s Leading Sales and Digital Marketing Coach. He is passionate about helping business owners, entrepreneurs and success minded people like you Accelerate Your Income, Live Your Dreams and Build Your Business. Cameron is a Dynamic Speaker, Business Success Coach, Digital Marketing Consultant, Sales Expert and Mentor who equips his students and gets results for his clients so that they thrive financially in any economic environment.
infusionsoft

robertcarter

I told my dentist my teeth are going yellow.

You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.

If you found your way here by running a search for the “best dentist in North Sydney” or the “best cosmetic dentist in North Sydney”, we’re gratified but we can’t publicly endorse the claim. Nor can any other dentist that you found as a result of running the search.

dentist north sydney

robertcarter

No power on earth has a right to take our property from us

This information is very helpful.Thank you for sharing the information,
After independently spending several years in the property game, and through investing hundreds of thousands of dollars’ on our education, we discovered there are so many options out there for people in different types of financial situations … and most people don’t even know about them!
avoid home repossession NSW

Follow News-Times:

News-Times Video »

CONTACT US

  • Main: 706-868-1222
  • Fax: 706-823-6062
  • Email: cnt@newstimesonline.com
  • 4272 Washington Rd, Suite 3B, Evans, Ga. 30809

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES